Condition Monitoring & Custom Products

        Vibration Monitoring and Machine Protection Systems

        League City Texas     Phone: 800-845-3028 or 281-334-0766     Fax: 281-334-4255

 

 

 

Home

Products

Datasheets

Manuals

About STI

Find a Rep

Application Notes

Technical Notes

e-Store Buy Online
Vibration Sensors
Mounting Hardware
Eddy Probe Accessories
Cables & Connectors
NEMA Enclosures
BNC Junction Boxes
BNC Switch Boxes
Transmitters
2-Wire Transmitters
Monitors
Monitoring Systems
HMI Systems
Tachometers
Analog to Digital Converters
Industrial Radios
Balancing Kits
TSI Systems
Demonstration Kits
Training Seminar
Used Equipment
STI Warranty
Links
Sales Tools

 

Cooling Tower Fan Monitoring


Cooling Tower Fan Diagram

Cooling Tower Fan

Overview

Cooling Tower Fans have applications in many industries, and in most of these cooling is a reasonably critical process and warrants monitoring. Cooling Tower Fans come in two basic types, the first type has the motor mounted to the side of the cell and uses a jackshaft to drive the gearbox in the beneath the fan the second type has both the motor and gearbox centrally mounted in the cell. The mechanical components of a Cooling Tower Fan are made up of, Motor, Jackshaft (Optional), Gearbox, and Fan Blades.

The most common Cooling Tower Fan failure involves the gearbox or fan blades and are catastrophic in nature. In many cases, this type of failure leaves the gearbox and fan blades lying in the cooling water pond at the bottom of the tower.

Many Cooling Tower Fans were equipped by the OEM (Original Equipment Manufacture) with a earthquake detection type devices mounted close to the cell. Although questionable to start with for this application, over time most of these devices have quit working due to corrosion or neglect.

Permanent monitoring is the recommended solution for preventing cooling tower cell failures. Periodic measurement programs rarely produce the desired result. In most cases, the location and environment discourages any attempts to take data or visually inspect the fan.

A permanent and continuous monitoring system offers several advantages for monitoring cooling towers. The first advantage is the sensors can be mounted directly on the bearing support parts on the motor and the gear so bearing condition, as well as casing vibration can be easily and accurately measured. The two levels of alarm offered by the CMCP500 Series Monitors can be set so operators can be made aware of potential problems at early stages of development before a condition becomes critical, and the second level of alarm can be used for shutdown.
 

Low Cost Solution

A continuous monitoring system, such as the CMCP500 Series, offers a low cost modular system ideally suited to monitoring cooling towers. Each 500 series monitor includes vibration detection, alert and danger set points, and alarms with relays.
 

A standard system, per cell, consists of two accelerometers, one on the motor inboard bearing and one on the gear near the input shaft bearing. Both of the accelerometers are mounted in the horizontal plane. Two CMCP500 Series Monitors are used , one for each sensor, which convert the sensor signal to a velocity vibration and provide the alarming features.

 

This system will provide continuous monitoring and protection for both the drive motor and gear assembly at a minimum level. Alternate configurations would include a second accelerometer on the outboard bearing of the motor and a second, or even a third, accelerometer on the gear box. The second accelerometer would be mounted on the input shaft bearing in the vertical direction and the third accelerometer would be mounted on the back side of the gear housing in the axial direction.

 

System Expansion

A 4-20 mA output signal is provided on all CMCP500 Series Transmitters and Monitors. This signal can be used as an input for indicators, chart recorders, a PLC or a DCS system to log and display vibration levels as well as for trending.

Alarm Set Points

Cooling towers are different from most of the other machinery in the plant that has continuous monitoring. The same alert and danger set points for high speed rotating machinery is not applicable to cooling towers. All cooling towers vibrate more than standard machinery. If the alarm levels are not set high enough you will be victim to numerous false shut downs. Alarms set at 0.5 in/sec for alert and 0.8 in/sec for danger would be unheard of for high speed machinery, but are common on cooling tower gear assemblies. Also, a longer alarm delay time will avoid false alarms.

Gearbox Vibration

Permanent monitoring of a cooling tower fan cell requires direct monitoring of the most important component by mounting a transducer directly on the gearbox. This is often a high maintenance source due to aerodynamic loading from the fan, excessive loading on the gear teeth, and improper alignment of the gear to the motor.

Monitoring the gearbox can be accomplished by installing a single accelerometer on the gearbox in a horizontal orientation perpendicular to the jackshaft. The output signal should be routed to a CMCP530A Vibration Velocity Monitor. The CMCP530A monitor is specified to measure velocity for higher frequencies such as gear mesh. A second monitor can be specified to integrate the signal to displacement terms for lower frequencies such as blade speed and blade pass. For this a CMCP535A displacement monitor should be used. If you wish to use a displacement monitor, the accelerometer will need to be replaced with a velocity transducer.

 

Motor Vibration

Motor vibration frequencies of interest include motor unbalance, rotor bar defects, output shaft alignment, and bearing defect frequencies. A complete continuous monitoring approach should include one accelerometer per bearing location. Mounting orientation for the accelerometers should be horizontal at the bearing. As the motor speed is usually 1800 RPM economical standard accelerometers such as the CMCP1100 can be used with a CMCP530A Vibration Monitor. A more economical approach would be to mount a single accelerometer at the motor output shaft bearing location only.

Start Up Considerations

All CMCP500 Series Monitors are provided with relays, reset terminals and a trip multiply function. Cooling Tower Fans experience large amounts of vibration during start-up. Either timer logic or a contact to energize trip multiply needs to be provided if the monitors are wired to shutdown.

DCS/PLC Systems

The CMCP500 series monitors can be equipped with Modbus or TCP/IP communications. I/O can be specified to provide operators with vibration levels, alarm set points, discrete alarms and the ability to energize the trip multiply and reset functions. A complete system using Modbus or TCP/IP can be specified providing operators with screens and software.

A complete vibration monitoring system includes:

Item Qty. P/N Description
1 2 CMCP1100 Low Cost Accelerometer
2 2

CMCP530A

Vibration Velocity Monitors
3 1 CMCP535A Vibration Displacement Monitor

For additional reading STI offers several application notes with a more in depth discussion at

STI Application Notes