| There are three basic
types of vibration transducers commonly used for machinery vibration
applications. They are the accelerometer, velometer, and the proximity
probe. Each transducer has its own unique application, and this guide is to
assist in selecting the proper sensor for your application.
Types Of Transducers
Accelerometers
Accelerometers are simply a piezoelectric crystal
with a mass/spring pre-load that creates a voltage proportional to
acceleration when subjected to acceleration. This signal is very faint,
measured in pico-volts and requires amplification by an internal electrical
circuit embedded in the accelerometer case.
Because of the piezoelectric accelerometers design, there is
usually insignificant internal mechanical motion, making accelerometers
virtually immune to mechanical wear. However, excessive mechanical shock
from hard impacts or dropping on hard surfaces can
destroy the internal electronic components or fracture the piezoelectric
crystal.
Accelerometers generally have the widest frequency range and
certainly the highest. However, vibratory response and electrical signal
levels are limited at lower frequencies. Accelerometer outputs are usually tens or hundreds of
mV-per-g,
peak (1g = 386.1 in/sec2 = 9.8 meter/sec2). The most common output is
100mV/g.
Velocity Transducers
Velocity transducers, or velometers, consist of a movable fine-wire coil in a
magnetic field which generates a voltage by the Hall Effect principal of
physics. The voltage generated is proportional to the velocity of the coil
motion. Velometers do not usually require external power as signal levels are
usually great enough to be used without pre-amplification. Since there are
moving parts, velocity transducers are
more prone to wear and mechanical damage than the other
vibration transducers.
Velocity transducers have a frequency range lower than accelerometers, and
the signal levels cover a range generally useful in machinery applications.
Sensitivities are usually mV-per-inches-per-second (ips.), peak, with the
standard being 100mV/in/sec.
Proximity Probes
Proximity probes, also known as eddy probes, are constructed
of a small,
flat "pancake" fine wire coil covered by a thin, nonconductive, protective
sheath such as fiberglass or Ryton. A high frequency energizing current creates an electromagnetic field
around the coil areas which is sensitive to position and vibration of metals
near it. To interpret the signal generated by metals entering these fields,
an oscillator/ demodulator and energizing power source
(together called a ‘driver’) is required, as well as precisely
matched extension cable between the probe and driver.
The proximity probe is the only commonly used non-contact vibration
transducer. Non-conductive materials such as air, gas, and fluid between the
probe and metal surface have no effect on the signal. However, surface conditions (finish,
type of alloy, etc.), non-symmetry
(run-out) and other characteristics of the metal surface being sensed can
influence the signal for the driver. Wear is not normally a consideration in
proximity probes, but the coil sheath is very thin
and may be damaged by accidental impact.
Proximity probes have a very wide
frequency range and also the lowest of the three transducer types. Sensitivities
are usually on the order of 100 – 200 mV per mil (1 mil = 0.001
inch) peak-to-peak displacement. The gap distance between the probe coil and
sensed surface is usually limited to about 0.1 – 0.2 inch or less, but
systems with much wider probes can sense much greater distances.
Selecting A Transducer
Machine Speed
The most important factor that influences the choice of
transducers is machine shaft rotating speed. Shaft speed determines the
fundamental vibration frequency of interest since most signals occur at some
multiple of running speed. Generally, a proper transducer will yield usable
information over a range from 0.4 to several times (up to 10X) of running
speed). Where running speed is measured in Hertz, which is
cycles per second or RPM /
60.
Machinery Types and Elements
Another important criteria in selecting a vibration transducer
is the type of machinery being monitored. Machinery with blade or
vane elements; such as pumps, fans, compressors, and turbines, generate
vibration signals at frequencies equal to the number of
blades/vanes times the running speed. For example a 4 blade fan will have a
peak in the spectrum at 4X running speed. Accelerometers are often
required in these instances because they can pick up these higher
frequencies that are out of range for a velometer. The amplitude and utility of these signals are
strongly influenced by the relative mass of the blade compared to the shaft.
For example fans and pumps with relatively massive blades and vanes may yield much data
in this frequency range. But, turbine and compressor blades with relatively small mass with
respect to their large shaft mass often yield vibration signals which
may be less significant and difficult to sense and measure.
The most useful and practical source of vibration
signals is from bearing areas. Journal
bearings are excellent applications for proximity probes since it is
difficult to measure shaft vibration when the shaft is not in contact with
the journal bearing, the layer of lubricant dampens many of the vibration
signals. The proximity probe is able to detect shaft vibration directly from
the shaft. Antifriction bearings, roller bearings, generate useful vibration
signals at running speed and much higher frequencies associated with ball-pass frequencies,
which is the number of ball/roller elements times the running speed, and inner/outer race and cage related frequencies. These signals
indicate antifriction bearing conditions as well as other vibration
signals transmitted from other machine related sources. Accelerometers and
sometimes velocity transducers are the usual choice with anti-friction
bearings due to frequency response and difficulty in
mounting proximity probes.
Frequency Response
Vibration transducers are rated for the
frequency range over they provide accurate data. This is often
expressed as +/- some percentage or ‘dB’ (decibel) figure. The transducers
response should be relatively linear from about 1/2 to a few times the
machinery running speed frequency. Also check that the transducer is not
resonant in this range.
Signal Levels
Vibration transducers are also rated as to output. This is expressed as
mV per vibration unit
(mil, ips, or g). When the vibration levels of interest and the
corresponding transducer voltage output levels result in signals under 5 mV, electrical noise and grounding of the entire electrical
circuit must be carefully reviewed. Often it is more practical to select a
transducer that will provide a higher output to avoid the noise problems.
For additional reading visit:
STI's Application Notes |